Friday, November 7, 2008

The Bird Has Certainly Flown the Coop!!!!!

I have been an empty-nester for almost two years now and my son is a sophomore in college only a couple of hours away at UVA. However each time he comes home to visit, I go through a hard time bidding him good-bye.

They grow so fast!

Having come from a culture where children live home with their parents well into their adulthood and often even after they marry, assuming there are no financial and space constraints, it is very hard for me to accept that my son who is a first generation American has essentially flown the coop once he left for college. The difference between the teenagers growing up in India and the teenagers here in US in terms of independence is quite startling. The kids back home are rather over-protected and sheltered whereas here the young men and women are are exactly that-young adults at eighteen -confident and able to live on their own even if their parents are in the same town.

Sigh! It seems only yesterday that he was such a baby -where have all the years gone!

The kids here are well adept at holding jobs and working in the outside world at a young age whereas one of the major cultural differences between the American setup and the Indian culture is that Indian parents assume full financial responsibility for their children till they are able to establish their own careers. In total contrast in the US, a grown man or woman here living with his parents without an ostensibly valid reason would be generally considered a "loser" or a social misfit. Nothing could be further from the truth back home though I have to say things are changing there too...

Reaching the age of eighteen is no hallmark of adulthood in my native India as nothing really changes and children continue to live with their parents. If the parents are financially secure, there is no pressure on the children to find summer jobs or part-time jobs etc. Actually unless they are truly in dire straits, the Indian parents even if somewhat financially strapped would find it unthinkable to expect their high school children find jobs or employment. They would rather deprive themselves instead. What the parents really want their children to do is to focus on their academics, enjoy their childhood and take advantage of the parental support to prepare themselves for good careers. In other words, parental expectations are limited to demanding excellence in academics and respecting the family traditions and rules. The family home is the home of the offspring and the parental influence continues well into their adult lives. As I explained in my earlier article, multi-generational families are the norm in India's culture though the nuclear families of husband -wife and kids are increasingly becoming more common.




Our basset hound who considers my son the leader of the pack, takes his leaving for college even harder than I do.

I recall growing up with my six brothers in our family home, even though the house was bursting at the seams with so many of us. The only time, I recall my older brothers leaving home was when they went to college or found jobs out of town, but they always came back. One of my brothers lived with my parents in our family home though in an independent unit within the house till he moved out to accommodate his expanding family needs. I lived with my parents till I got married and arrived here.


Those were wonderful years in Delhi when I was a single high school teacher coming home after school to home-cooked meals and afternoon naps. I continued to follow the family rules without feeling stifled or missing privacy. Rather the bonds within the family were very strong. Here I am being greeted by my nephew and niece living in my parents' home in New Delhi.


Here we are a bunch of school teachers in New Delhi having fun, single and living with our parents and that was the norm.

Today it is interesting to watch the interplay of the two almost diametrically opposed cultures in the Indian-American children like my son born and brought up here. He is for all intents and purposes an all-American kid as in having his own space and privacy in my home but he is still not allowed to flout the rules and traditions that I have maintained from back home in India. It is not easy- I grant you that and it is a constant struggle to maintain that fine balance because kids here are very self-assured and know how to fend and more importantly think for themselves. So one has to tread carefully to blend the two value sets as seamlessly as possibly so as not put the child in a position of choosing one or the other because that is not healthy either and can lead to emotional issues stemming from lack of roots in either world...

Fortunately the Indian-American parents like me are trying to go with the flow. Every now and then I will get mad at my free-talking son, but then force myself to remember that kids here are taught to freely express their opinions and that that is not "talking back" as we were programmed to think in our days... Many of my Indian-American friends young daughters who are professionals are living in the same city but in their own places. The parents have made peace. The trick is to remember that American culture is individualistic and teaches the children to be extremely independent and this has to be balanced with the Indian cultural norms of togetherness which on the other hand can be quite smothering. Frankly, I think our Indian-American kids are actually getting the best of both worlds - I truly believe that and now I just need to- as they say here - get with the program, get a life and let go!

Anyway enough of reminiscing and philosophizing, it is time to head to Candid Carrie Friday Foto Fiesta and check what's happening there... Follow me!

18 comments:

Susie said...

I know...my oldest is in college and I wish we had a culture where the children lived with us. It's hard to let go.

~~tonya~~ said...

Wow, what a great post. Thanks for the insight. And yes, I do wish they would stay home a little longer.

The Other Carey Sue said...

I too wish they would stay longer...it does feel like we throw them to the wolves at a very young age..."OK, you're 18 figure it out." I know that's extreme, but it sure seems like that's what we do.

Like I've said in previous posts of yours-I would love to adapt some of your traditions...I really miss my parents and would welcome them with open arms if we could live together...my kids as well.

Thank you for sharing and your son is very nice looking...like his mother!!:)

Lauren said...

Interesting. My friend Neeta had a similar experience to what you write. I think it was hard for her with her son who was not a momma's boy and really treated her badly as a young adult and yet she worshiped him as he was her male child. hard for her.

Come by for my fiesta foto and Caption This contest where 275 entrecard credits are up for grabs.

RBK's Realm said...

Lauren,

It is true that in India, sons are premium but it is all changing now and in my case, I would find it equally hard to let go a daughter at 18 also, if not harder since the mother-daughter bond is even closer generally - at least mine was...

Fortunately, my son and I are close without him being a momma's boy. Ours relationship is based on mutual respect and boundaries - I don't think either of us would accept anything less :)

cyclingred said...

From what I have read about other countries, I think the U.S. may be the exception and India more the rule.

Yet even in America young adults are staying financially dependent on their parents to an older age than they did a generation or two ago.

My youngest is about to leave. Wahoo! I like having them close but it is nice also not to be completely responsible for them.

Anonymous said...

I will watch a son walk out of my house someday too, never to return permanently, but rather for mere visits. It will be hard to handle, for sure. However, I'm equally looking foward to seeing what he does with his life and where it will take him. He fascinates me every day with his own developing mind and preferences. I don't think our kids can really grow under our wings as well as they do once they are on their own. As parents, we tend to pamper, protect, and offer "advice." When they have to get those answers from within themselves is when they really get interesting. -DT

Candid Carrie said...

Alright, once more you have given us so much information. I love the way your post today not only shared the present but the way you dipped into your past was a great way to help us understand more about you.

Your son is really good looking! My second oldest son is a sophomore at college too. I marvel at how he looks different, smells different and how people that I've never met are a part of his life ... will we ever get used to this?

BoufMom9 said...

OMGosh! I am all teary reading this. I don't look forward to the day the kids start moving out.

lmerie said...

Beautiful Post! I am glad you posted on Candid Carrie . . .

david mcmahon said...

G'day from Australia, from an Indian-born and Indian-educated blogger.

I can identify with this post very strongly.

Head Nut said...

what a great post!! and wonderful phamily photos!!

a.men said...

Time does go by way to fast!

Ronda's Rants said...

In either culture...I am sure they grow up too soon! I know you understand fully my feelings as our son gets married! I am so verp pleased with his choice of a wife ...she is wonderful and I already love her as a daughter (they have had a long engagement as she is still in college!) I just miss them! I enjoy your perspectives very much!

Teri said...

Thank you so much for sharing this wonderful information. I have a hard time letting go of my kids the older they get. I know they need to gain indepenence, but I sometimes realize that I am not ready to stop being needed as a Mom. It's tough.

Great post.

Sandi McBride said...

I know this feeling...my father is from Equador and my mother from here in South Carolina...it was always a battle of upbringing between them...mostly my mother won. And that they grow so quickly...oh my...one day they arrive and in a few weeks seems they want the keys to the car! Lovely post...congratulations on Post of the Day mention!
Sandi

Carol said...

I have two sons who have both 'flown the coop'. I miss them. Terribly.

This was a great post. Congrats on Post of the Day!!

Malini said...

Hi again. Raksha I enjoy reading your blog especially because it triggers of a gamut of emotions and heated debates between you and me. Recollecting one of our passionate conversations over the issue you quelled the tide by reminding me that my observations were based on a small community nestling in the beautiful state of Washington. I would like to quote another fellow teacher who is on an exchange with me. She is teaching in one of the top private schools in one of the most prosperous cities of the US
"This Camp is meant to make the high school children aware of the existing problems in the society regarding discrimination on the basis of races, gender and opportunities. This helps in their taking up the responsibility of changing this situation (developing potential leaders from them).I have realised the magnitude of the problems of drugs among school kids, sexual abuse and broken or separated families and its impact on the young minds. Many of the girls have been in one form or the other sexually abused at some point in their life and these girls of the ages of 14-18 literally break down relating their experiences. So it is no way a fun camp.
I used to be mentally exhausted at the end of the day. But my staff friends Lynda and Lizzie where there and we stayed together thru the whole process, giving mental and psychological support to each other. It was shocking for them too so they understood what I felt."
She is feeling the same angst that I have been. My interaction with the high school kids has led to many questions. I am sure the pioneering American sees a lot of good in the individualism that he so passionately believes in does need to stop and look at the impact on young minds. Maybe there can be participation in making the roadmap and the creative individualism of the young adult based on “choice” does need some smothering of family togetherness ...It maybe a solution. Thinking from the heart is a great feeling. This is just a personal response. Great writing but I am still looking for my answers.